Skip to Content

Lake Shore Solid Pack Pumpkin Pie Recipe

Sharing is caring!

A slice of pumpkin pie sitting on a stack of 3 white plates with a fork. There's a linen napkin on the wooden table and a small pumpkin in the background.

There is no denying that Libby’s dominates the canned pumpkin scene, but there is an Upstate New York Player with a considerably cooler looking label you may have noticed while shopping at Tops Markets.

I happened upon Lake Shore Solid Pack Pumpkin while shopping at Tops Friendly Markets recently, being significantly closer to Rochester than Buffalo, I had never heard of Lake Shore Pumpkin, but could not resist the label and when I picked up a can of the pumpkin to further check out the colorful imagery, I happened to notice this is actually a regional product, with roots in Buffalo. So I promptly threw two cans of pumpkin in my cart with plans to research the pumpkin packed in the can with the odd little label later that night.

Lake Shore Solid Pack Pumpkin Information and History

I was hoping to find a company or brand history as unique as the label the solid pack pumpkin sports, but that wasn’t to be, this is instead what I could find out:

Lake Shore Solid Pack Pumpkin is distributed by NTC Marketing which is based out of Williamsville, New York. After a lot of confusing research here is what I learned about NTC Marketing and Lake Shore Pumpkin:

  • NTC Marketing owns the Tropical Fruit Libby’s Brand,  based out of Buffalo they specialize in pineapple, and other canned tropical fruits.
  • Libby’s Pumpkin and Libby’s Tropical Fruits are not the same!
  • Yes, there is a connection to Libby’s Pumpkin products, but it goes WAY back. Libby’s was founded as Libby, McNeill & Libby in Chicago, Illinois, by Archibald McNeill and the brothers Arthur and Charles Libby in 1875. Over the years the original company was divided and acquired by multiple other companies. Libby, McNeill & Libby was acquired by Nestlé in 1976, and Nestlé still holds the trademark and licensing for Libby’s brand pumpkin. NTC Marketing acquired Libby’s licenses for pineapple and tropical fruits in 1983 and juices in 2009.

As for the Lake Shore Pumpkin despite being manufactured or distributed by a Marketing Company, I can find no website, brand history, or even mention of the product on NTC’s main website which is listed on the can of pumpkin.

Google did turn up a couple of interesting results though, a site called Trademarkia, where users had left glowing reviews reading ” Trust me LAKE SHORE PUMPKIN IS the BEST!!!!” and “My family swears by the Lakeshore brand canned pumpkin for our families holiday pies”.  On another site, a user shared the recipe on the back of the Lake Shore Pumpkin Pie Recipe, which also was highly praised.

The Iconic Lake Shore Pumpkin Can

Like Grandma Brown’s the can Lake Shore Pumpkin Can is easy to spot on grocery store shelves.  The vintage look of the label seems to fly in the face of the general trend to design labels using principles of psychology,  target market research and demographic data.

A 15-ounce can on Lake Shore Solid Pack Pumpkin sitting on a kitchen counter with an egg in the background.

There is a little man or Dutch boy?? in nothing more than an apron (if you look closely you can see a sliver of his backside) standing on a stump, stirring a giant pumpkin kettle of what we can assume to be pumpkin puree adorning the label of Lake Shore pumpkin. Honestly, I have no idea what is going on in this odd little cooking scene on the label, but I love it for all its kitschy-nostalgic-ness.

On the back side of the label is the recipe for the pumpkin pie I mentioned earlier.  I don’t usually ever share recipes I haven’t made myself at least once, but because it is one week until Thanksgiving, I am going to hold out and bake this when I bake the rest of my pies.  I will update with photos and my own observations after Turkey Day!

How To Make Lake Shore Pumpkin Pie

Lake Shore Pumpkin Pie is super easy to make! You will have to have a pie crust at the ready, you can use your favorite homemade recipe or a store bought version.

  • Line a 9″ pie plate with a pie crust.
  • Combine your filling ingredients and stir to combine.
  • Pour into prepared crust.
  • Bake and cool.
  • Serve Chilled and enjoy!!

How to know when Pumpkin Pie is done? You will know your pumpmkin pie is done cooking when you give you pumpkin pie a gentle shake and the filling still has a slight jiggle but is not wet or wiggly. Make sure you allow it to cool on a rack to allow it to finish setting.

Baking and Serving Pumpkin Pie

  • This recipe makes 2 8-inch pies, but I’ve had great results halving the recipe for a single pie using a whole 15-ounce can of solid pack pumpkin
  • Brushing the crust with a lightly beaten egg white helps keep the crust from becoming soggy.
  • Pumpkin pie sets as it cools, so it is best served chilled. Cool a freshly baked pumpkin pie for at least 4 hours before serving.
  • Pumpkin pie is great on it’s own, but I also love serving it with whipped cream, whipped topping, or vanilla ice cream.
  • Pumpkin pie is essentially a custard and should be stored in the fridge. The pie will keep in refrigeration for 3-4 days

Lake Shore Solid Pack Pumpkin Pie Recipe

Lake Shore Solid Pack Pumpkin Pie

Lake Shore Solid Pack Pumpkin Pie

Yield: Makes 2 9-inch Pies
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 40 minutes
Total Time: 55 minutes

This traditional holiday pumpkin pie recipe that is found on the back of the Lake Shore Solid Pack Pumpkin can labels . This pie is easy to prepare, just mix, pour, bake for a delicious Upstate New York homemade tradition.

Ingredients

  • 4 eggs
  • 29 ounces Lake Shore solid pack pumpkin
  • 1 1/2 cups cups sugar
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 2 teaspoons cinnamon
  • 1 teaspoon ginger
  • 1 teaspoon allspice
  • 2 cups milk
  • 2 9-inch pie crusts

Instructions

  1. Mix well beaten eggs, pumpkin, sugar, salt and spices. Add milk and stir until mixture is smooth.
  2. Line two 9-inch pie pans with pastry.
  3. Pour filling into the pastry shells, dividing it equally.
  4. Bake in a hot oven (400 degrees) about 45 minutes, or until a knife inserted halfway between center and edge comes out clean.

Notes

This recipe makes 2 9-inch pies, but I've had great results halving the recipe for a single pie using a whole 15-ounce can of canned pumpkin

Nutrition Information:
Yield: 16 Serving Size: 1
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 215Total Fat: 7gSaturated Fat: 3gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 4gCholesterol: 49mgSodium: 257mgCarbohydrates: 34gFiber: 1gSugar: 21gProtein: 4g

*Nutrition Information does not include pie crust. Even though I try to provide accurate nutritional information to the best of my ability, these figures should still be considered estimates. Please see my Nutrition Disclaimer for more information.

I would really love to learn more about Lake Shore Pumpkin! Do you use Lake Shore Solid Pack Pumpkin, do you have any memories of holiday baking with it?

Cindy

Wednesday 24th of November 2021

“The ONLY canned pumpkin worth its salt,” as my Grandmother used to say. I am 68 years old and it’s the only pumpkin my family ever used for pie and bread. The label is a bit different than when I was young. I believe a Native American used to be on the can. Had a harder time getting it this year. Had to go to 3 Tops stores to find it. I send it to my sister in Nevada for her Thanksgiving, and I take it with me to Montana for Christmas at my daughter’s. Once you have a Lake Shore pumpkin pie, you will never want a Libby’s again!

Julie Rauth Shaw

Wednesday 24th of November 2021

I followed your recipe, but since it is holiday time and this year is particularly special to us, I substituted heavy cream for the milk, and the result is a decadently rich, velvety filling. I read somewhere that the little men on the Lakeshore can were "sprites", sort of like elves. I loved that can art, I trusted it growing up and wherever I had a choice, I always bought Lakeshore.

Gayle Forget

Tuesday 23rd of November 2021

I have always used Libbys' pumpkin. I never heard of your brand until now. We no longer live in NY State so getting to try your canned pumpkin will not happen. Where are your products sold in NY? We are originally from Plattsburgh, NY but have been gone for the past 12 years. Would love to try your Brand if my friends live where they could buy me a can and bring it South. Thanks for your time. Gayle

Joanne

Monday 22nd of November 2021

My mother-in-law gave me her recipe for pumpkin pie 48 years ago. It's the one on the back of the Lake Shore can, exactly as printed above. Since we are not currently residing in NY, no access to this pumpkin. M-I-L would be horrified if she knew her version of pumpkin pie was no longer available.

Dianne Grant

Monday 1st of November 2021

Lakeshore pumpkin I grew up on. Now it's hard to find in stores. I have ordered it by Buffalo I a box in the past. But the price and the shipping have has out priced my budget. Sadly I will not have pumpkin pie this Thanksgiving.

Deborah Coleman

Sunday 14th of November 2021

@Jennifer Morrisey, I was wondering how long an unopened can of Lake Shore Pumpkin Solid Pack can be safely used? Mine has a “Best By” Dec 2020. Couldn’t find anything on their website. Thank you

Jennifer Morrisey

Tuesday 2nd of November 2021

Dianne Grant, I still haven't been able to get my hands on any either! I feel like other brands of canned pumpkins are more watery. I may try making my own pumpkin puree. But not being able to find Lakeshore is disappointing. I hope you have a happy and healthy holiday :-)

Skip to Recipe