Skip to Content

Pretty Egg Packaging: Vintage Style Egg Cartons

Sharing is caring!

Vintage Style Egg Cartons are a beautiful way to showcase your farm fresh eggs! These are the best supplies to give your egg packaging irresistible farmhouse appeal.

If you are looking into selling eggs or want your eggs to stand out at the farmer’s market, don’t underestimate the importance of beautiful, memorable packaging. Packaging your farm fresh eggs in a charming, eye-catching way is very easy and much LESS expensive than you may think!

2 half dozen close egg cartons sitting on a white table tops. One carton is marked "Hand Gathered" and has a banyard scene with chickens on it, the other is marked with "Fresh Eggs" with a chicken graphic on it.  there are a dozen multi colored fresh eggs slightly out of focus in the background and a vintage kitchen scale.

Attractive stamped egg cartons draw potential buyers’ attention and reflect the care you put into your flock. Customers are also willing to pay a little more for thoughtfully and carefully packed eggs. It’s hard to resist fresh farm eggs packaged with vintage country charm!

You’ll find my favorite tips, tricks, and products are to give your eggs that irresistible vintage farmhouse appeal below.

Why Vintage Style Packaging for Eggs?

I have a fondness for all things vintage and old-fashioned aesthetics, so of course, I will be drawn to charming nostalgic packaging. But I am not alone in thinking eggs in vintage-style cartons make sense. As you will see briefly, there are plenty of options for beautiful vintage-inspired egg cartons.

I am not an expert on consumer behaviors and have never taken a consumer psychology class. But I think that most people buying farm-fresh eggs at a local farmer’s market are looking to avoid food produced in large-scale commercial facilities. A nostalgic carton featuring an idyllic design evokes small family farms, country life, and simpler times. It sets your fresh eggs apart from what’s offered in stores.

Purchasing food at a farmer’s market or roadside stand is an experience. Beautiful packaging enhances the customer’s experience. A hand-stamped carton can make a stunning first impression that reflects the amount of care you have put into your flock. Shoppers can enjoy the experience of buying beautifully packaged eggs that are of higher quality than those they’d find at the store.

Stand Out With Stamped and Printed Egg Cartons

Whether you are selling hatching or eating eggs, buyers adore the attractive, reusable packaging, and gift recipients will appreciate the irresistibly cute farmhouse charm! If you are interested in stepping up your packaging, you have a couple of options. You can either buy printed egg cartons or invest in a rubber stamp and add your branding onto blank egg cartons.

Comply with State and Federal Laws

Whatever method you choose, research your state’s egg selling laws to see what information you must have on the carton and select your stamp(s) accordingly. You can find New York State’s Regulations for Selling Eggs On the Cornell Cooperative Extension Website.

Federal law requires that cartons intended for sale marked with “Fresh” or “Farm Fresh” must have been professionally inspected and graded. It is OK to use the word “Fresh” on free eggs being gifted. But you should opt for “Hand Gathered Eggs,” “Farmhouse Eggs,” or similar wording if selling at farmer’s markets. FDA Safe Egg Handling instructions must appear on the outside of your carton, and should read:

SAFE HANDLING INSTRUCTIONS: To prevent illness from bacteria: keep eggs refrigerated, cook eggs until yolks are firm, and cook foods containing eggs thoroughly.

Printed Egg Cartons

If you are on the fence about your branding, you may be hesitant to invest in a complete stamping system. I have found generic Stamped Cartons from Amazon to be a nice compromise. I still get the adorable vintage style graphics and lettering, but without any long-term commitment. There are some super cute egg cartons available on Amazon. I am currently using the Henlay Split carton and love it. Because it is designed to be split in half for a half dozen eggs, the center of the carton is a little weaker, but I still find them to be great-looking and durable.

Vintage Design Egg Cartons for Farm Fresh Eggs, Recycled Paper Cardboard
$29.99

These egg cartons bring a fresh look, a vintage feel, and are built strong.You'll love these egg cartons to proudly display your beautiful, farm fresh eggs. The vintage farmhouse design is sure to create a lovely first impression, and look darling in the kitchen.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/04/2022 03:03 pm GMT
Full or Half Dozen!
Printed Empty Egg Cartons- Securely Holds 6 or 12 Extra Large Eggs
$22.99

The vintage farmhouse design on these cartons is sure draw attention whether you are sharing with friends and family, or selling at the local farmer’s market. These cartons are sturdy, strong, and made in the USA. If you will be selling your eggs the required safe handling instructions will need to be added along with your personal information depending on the requirements of your state.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/04/2022 03:53 pm GMT

Custom Egg Carton Stamps

Hand stamping your egg cartons is a cost-effective way to customize your egg cartons with your farm name or family name and meet the local and federal required labeling. There are SO many cute options on Etsy, and I really enjoy working with small sellers vs. large companies.
I have worked with Etsy sellers to mock up rubber stamps for my egg cartons. Right now, two of my favorite Etsy Shops for Egg Carton Stamps are Authentic Heirlooms and Silver Homestead. I’ve listed some of my favorite items from their shops below! But no matter who you decide to work with, I have a couple of tips for you:

  • Many Etsy sellers do not accept returns, exchanges, or cancellations on custom orders. Make sure the seller can supply you with a digital proof of what your stamp will look like once completed. Even if only the text is being customized. Capitalization, font choices, and even kerning between letters all affect the look of the final stamp.
  • Not all rubber stamps are created equal! You’ll want a good-quality rubber stamp that can hold up for a long time and produce a clear image. Do your research to find a reputable seller that can create high-quality work.
  • Invest in a good ink pad! (Ranger Archival is a good brand). Keep in mind the size of your stamp when purchasing your ink pad.
FDA Compliancy Stamp
Safe Handling Egg Carton Rubber Stamp 0.75x4 Inch
$30.00

United States FDA law requires Safe Handling Instructions appear on the outside of every carton of shell eggs that have not been treated to destroy Salmonella. But that doesn’t mean it can't be cute!

This vintage farmhouse style 0.75 x 4 inch stamp fits front and back carton edges on half dozen and full dozen pulp egg cartons. 

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
Customizable!
Customizable Egg Carton Stamp | Etsy
$41.00

This versatile egg carton stamp lets you customize your egg cartons, hang tags and other packaging with your family or farm name. Measuring 4 inches wide by 2 inches tall, these stamps work beautifully on flat-top half dozen, full dozen, and vintage dozen cartons.


All of the lines of text on this stamp can be customized by the seller!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
Return Stamp
Please Return Clean Carton Egg Carton Stamp Fresh Eggs | Etsy
$18.00

Encourage your customers to return clean egg cartons!

This stamp is designed to be stamped directly on egg cartons and requests that the carton please be returned. This stamp has a cute farmhouse look that features a chicken on either side of the “Please Return Carton” message.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
Social Media Branding
Social Media Stamp
$24.00

Encourage your customers to stay in touch on social media! This Follow Us stamp is a great way to get your customers to connect with you online. This stamps are customizable with your website or social media handle.

This stamp features an elegant design that will work with many different stamp styles.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Blank Egg Cartons

If you are going to personalize your egg cartons with customized rubber stamps, you will need plain or blank egg cartons. Look for egg cartons made out of recycled cardboard material. I have found it sturdy and more substantial than paper pulp egg cartons. Recycled cardboard cartons are sturdy enough to be reused but still biodegradable and compostable.

Classic Style
75 Vintage Blank Egg Cartons- Classic 3x4 Style Holds 12 Large Eggs, Made from Recycled Cardboard
$82.99 ($1.11 / Count)

The classic shape of these egg cartons are sure to showcase your eggs and grab customers attention. The egg cells are in a 4 by 3 configuration (square with slanted sides) and fit small to large eggs.

The egg cartons are blank with a smooth top finish that is the perfect canvas for personalization with rubber stamps. 

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/04/2022 03:38 pm GMT
Half Dozen Size
100 Half Dozen Egg Cartons
$64.99

The cute style of these cartons makes an excellent packaging for farm fresh eggs! Henlay cartons are sturdy and strong, made from recycled cardboard, which is stronger the paper pulp. They feature a double clasp in the front to safely secure the heaviest eggs. The interior pillars add stability and protect the carton from crushing. The flat top measures 5” x 3.25” and is perfect for adding a custom stamp or decal. 

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/04/2022 03:28 pm GMT
Jumbo Egg Cartons
100 Duck Egg Cartons- Holds Half Dozen Jumbo Eggs
$79.99

 If your flock includes waterfowl, like ducks or geese, these cartons are for you! These cartons are sturdy and strong, made from recycled cardboard, which is stronger the paper pulp. They feature a double clasp in the front to safely secure the heaviest eggs. The interior pillars add stability and protect the carton from crushing. The flat top measures 4” x 5.25” and is perfect for adding a custom stamp or decal.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/04/2022 09:56 am GMT
Standard Size and Shape
Blank Egg Carton 150 pcs

These solid and sturdy egg cartons are the standard size and shape many people are used to. Cartons are blank with absolutely no printing. These egg cartons hold 12 small to extra large eggs in the standard two-row cell configuration. They are made from 100% reclaimed paper. 

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
2 half dozen close egg cartons sitting on a white table tops. One carton is marked "Hand Gathered" and has a banyard scene with chickens on it, the other is marked with "Fresh Eggs" with a chicken graphic on it.  there are a dozen multi colored fresh eggs slightly out of focus in the background and a vintage kitchen scale.

I think packaging eggs in pretty vintage-style cartons to create a memorable brand that enhances your customer’s experience is a great idea. Vintage-style cartons can create a sense of nostalgia and reflect the amount of care you’ve put into your backyard flock. How do you package your eggs?