Oh my gosh, this cinnamon roll filling is it, guys!
I love cinnamon rolls, but I could never figure out how to get the consistency of the filling right. some fillings turned out too dry and baked right into the dough, and some too thin and would run out of the roll to the bottom of the pan. I wanted cinnamon rolls with really thick and gooey cinnamon filling.
I thought my problems were solved with I stumbled upon King Arthur’s Baker’s Cinnamon Filling, this stuff is amazing, think mall cinnamon rolls. My only problem? $10 + shipping to make 5 loaves of bread.
You know I love mixing my own versions of stuff up in my kitchen, and I have been itching to come up with a copycat of Baker’s cinnamon roll filling. It took me a while to figure out how to get a schmear like filling, and it actually happened when I was cleaning out my kitchen cupboards and ran across some instant clear gel left over from canning season.
Instant Clear Gel is a modified corn starch, if you have ever canned pie filling you have most likely used this stuff. Unlike regular cornstarch, Instant Clear Gel has excellent heat and acid resistance, so it is perfectly suited for canned pie fillings that are heated during the canning process and then again when you are baking a pie.
A very strong word of recommendation when working with instant clear gel. They are not kidding when they say INSTANT. It is highly concentrated, and requires no cooking or heat to thicken. ALWAYS mix instant clear gel with sugar before adding any liquids, or you will have a sticky sloppy mess on your hands. I buy my Instant clear gel at my favorite Mennonite bulk foods store, but you can order it on Amazon. I would be willing to bet Instant clear gel is exactly what is in King Arthur’s Baker’s Cinnamon Filling.
At the risk of sounding like our favorite FoodNetwork host, this is one of those situations where you really want to use the best cinnamon you can get your hands on. I mean cinnamon rolls are supposed to be cinnamon-y, right? I am a fan of Saigon cinnamon, if you are looking for something you can pick up at the store Spice Islands Saigon Cinnamon is the best I have found on my grocery store shelves.
Baker's Cinnamon Filling Recipe
- 3/4 c brown sugar
- 2 tsp cinnamon
- 1 1/2 tablespoons instant clear gel(powder)
- a few tbsp water
- In a bowl combine brown sugar, cinnamon and Instant clear gel, stir to thoroughly combine.
- Add water 1/2 a tablespoon at a time to reach desired schmear consistency. I usually 2 1/2-3 tablespoons, but it really depends on the moisture content of your brown sugar.
- Spread on dough and bake as specified by recipe.
There may be affiliate links in this post. By clicking on them, or purchasing recommended items I may receive a small compensation, at no cost to you. However, I only recommend products I absolutely love and use in my own home! Thank you for supporting Home in the Finger Lakes when you shop! See my disclosure policy for more info.
Looking for a super easy and good yeast dough to go with this filling? I will be posting my favorite cinnamon roll recipe Thursday, You will love it!